In The Crucible, the affair between John Proctor (30s) and Abigail Williams (17) is not a simple villain-victim dynamic. Both bear responsibility:
Abigail: Initiates the advances. Pursues Proctor after he ends it. Weaponizes the witchcraft accusations to eliminate Elizabeth—calculated, malicious.
John Proctor: Engages knowing Abigail's youth, vulnerability, and dependence. Exploits the power imbalance (employer, adult, male). Understands the consequences for his wife and family—and proceeds.
Abigail's subsequent villainy does not erase Proctor's initial transgression. Proctor's later heroism does not excuse his initial failure. The tragedy erupts from both flaws: her ruthlessness, his weakness. Miller distributes guilt to show that evil often arises from ordinary human failings—lust, pride, fear—magnified by circumstance.