The 1977 film Julia, starring Jane Fonda as Lillian Hellman and Vanessa Redgrave as Julia, was marketed as an adaptation of Hellman's 1975 memoir Pentimento. The book portrays Hellman's 1930s friendship with Julia, an American woman from a wealthy family who allegedly worked for the anti-fascist resistance in Europe.
However, historical investigation—most notably by Samuel McCracken in Commentary (1982) and later by Hellman's critics—strongly suggests that "Julia" may have been a fabrication or, more damningly, that the real figure behind the character was a Nazi collaborator or spy, not an anti-fascist. Hellman's account has been widely disputed; Mary McCarthy's famous quip—"Every word she writes is a lie, including 'and' and 'the'"—captures the literary feud.
The film, directed by Fred Zinnemann, won three Oscars but remains entangled in the controversy over Hellman's veracity. It is a case study in how memoir, memory, and history collide—and how cinema can cement a contested narrative.