Why Richard III Is So Devious: Ambition Unmoored from Conscience
Richard III's Machiavellian Architecture
Shakespeare's Richard (historical Richard III reimagined) is devious because he treats morality as a tool, not a constraint. His ambition (the crown) is absolute; every person is an obstacle or instrument.
Six Calculated Deceptions
- Frames Clarence: Accuses brother of treason via prophecy ("G of Edward's heirs the murderer shall be") → Clarence imprisoned → murdered in wine vat. Richard inherits Clarence's lands.
- Betrays Edward, Prince of Wales: Pretends loyalty to nephew/king → imprisons him in Tower → orders murder (with Buckingham).
- Marries Anne Neville: Wooes widow of Prince Edward (whom Richard killed) at her husband's funeral. "I'll have her, but I will not keep her long." Political utility → discards.
- Manipulates Lady Anne: Turns her grief/rage into acceptance via rhetoric: "Your beauty was the cause of that effect."
- Eliminates the Princes: Orders Tyrell to murder Edward V and Richard of York (Tower). Removes all Yorkist claimants.
- Fabricates evidence against allies: Accuses Buckingham & Hastings of treason → executes them. "Thus I clothe my naked villainy / With odd old ends stol'n forth of holy writ."
Psychological Core
- Self-awareness: "I am determined to prove a villain" (1.1) – he chooses villainy.
- Deformity as justification: "Cheated of feature by dissembling nature" → outward deformity licenses inward corruption.
- Performance as survival: He acts (lover, mourner, loyal brother, pious king) – each role a mask.
Downfall
Deception requires increasing complexity. Each lie needs two more. At Bosworth, ghosts of his victims haunt him—externalized conscience. "Despair and die" vs. Richmond's "God and our good cause fight on our side." The deceiver is finally deceived by his own shadows.