Shakespeare's decision to end Romeo and Juliet in tragedy was driven by a convergence of source fidelity, structural necessity, thematic depth, and Elizabethan theatrical conventions. Far from arbitrary, the tragic conclusion elevates the play from romance to enduring legend.
Arthur Brooke's The Tragical History of Romeus and Juliet (1562), Shakespeare's primary source, ends in tragedy. Shakespeare compressed the timeline from nine months to five feverish days but retained the fatal arc.
The Montague-Capulet hatred functions as a machine that grinds private love into dust. No personal affection can survive such public, systemic enmity.
Romeo and Juliet act on immediate feeling—they marry within hours and die within days. Their intensity is precisely their tragedy; there is no space for reflection or moderation.
The prologue's "star-cross'd lovers" sets the tone. A misdelivered letter, a mistimed waking, a plague quarantine—coincidence operates as cosmic conspiracy, stripping the lovers of agency.
Public executions, religious tension, and recurrent plague made death proximate for Shakespeare's audience. Tragedy affirmed moral order: disorder (the feud) leads to chaos (the deaths) and finally restoration (the gold statues).
Aristotelian pity and fear purge the audience. A happy ending would feel unearned, trivializing the stakes. The tragedy makes the love legendary; survival would render it merely a romance.