Ismene is far more than "the sister who says no." She serves four essential dramatic purposes:
Antigone: divine law > state law, action > safety, individual > collective.
Ismene: state law > divine law (initially), survival > martyrdom, family unity > individual conscience.
Without Ismene, Antigone's extremity lacks contrast.
She voices what the audience feels: "We are only women... we must obey." Her realism makes Antigone's heroism visible as choice, not inevitability.
Ismene's arguments are reasonable: burial risks both sisters' lives, leaves no one to continue the family line, obeys legitimate authority. The play refuses easy "right vs. wrong" binaries.
Ismene's refusal forces Antigone into solitary action—the condition of tragic heroism. Later, Ismene's attempt to share guilt ("I did it too") deepens Antigone's isolation: she won't accept false solidarity.
Ismene lives to carry the story—the vessel of memory. Antigone dies; Ismene remains to testify.
Sophocles uses Ismene to humanize the stakes: heroism costs not just the hero, but everyone who loves them.