Arthur Conan Doyle’s novel uses multiple layers of irony:
The legend of a phantom hound creates dread, but the culprit uses science (phosphorus‑coated dog) for human greed—undermining the supernatural.
Characters suspect the innocent and overlook the guilty. Stapleton hides behind a scholarly facade, betraying trust.
Sir Charles dies from an induced heart attack, a product of his family’s cursed reputation. The fabricated legend persists even after exposure.
Holmes is initially misled by the supernatural ruse. Watson, the "ordinary" narrator, provides crucial observations.
These ironies deepen the mystery and highlight themes of reason vs. superstition.