Gunnar Myrdal's "American Dilemma" (1944)
Core Definition: The **contradiction between the "American Creed" (liberty, equality, justice for all) and the systemic reality of **Black oppression** (segregation, disenfranchisement, violence, economic exploitation).
Book: *An American Dilemma: The Negro Problem and Modern Democracy* (1944)
- Carnegie Corporation-funded, 1,500+ pages, 70+ researchers (incl. Ralph Bunche, Kenneth Clark).
- Thesis: White Americans hold **high ideals** but practice **discrimination** → **moral cognitive dissonance** = "The Dilemma."
- Mechanism: **Caste system** (race) overrides **class system** (economics). Even poor whites rank above Blacks.
- Consequence: Democracy undermined; "Negro problem" is a **white problem** (moral failure).
Impact
- Cited in **Brown v. Board of Education** (1954)—"separate is inherently unequal."
- Shaped **Civil Rights Movement** framing (moral appeal to creed).
- Established **social science** as policy tool.
Myrdal (Swedish economist, Nobel 1974) framed it as **universal test of democratic integrity**—unresolved today.