Likely The Summer House (1993) — also known as Summer House — starring Peter Coyote and Jenny Wright.
Alternate possibility: The Crush (1993, Alicia Silverstone/Cary Elwes) — but that's obsession, not country club/sister murder.
If not The Summer House, share: year, actors, more plot details (sister's death cause, framing method, ending). The 1993 thriller fits many of the described elements, but several similar films exist in that era's "yuppie nightmare" subgenre.