Arguments for Babette not being evil:
* She's a victim: She's trapped in the Beast's castle just like the other enchanted objects. She longs for freedom and a life outside the castle.
* She's not cruel: Unlike Gaston, she doesn't actively try to harm Belle or anyone else. She's more concerned with her own well-being and desires.
* She has a sense of humor: She enjoys teasing Cogsworth and Lumiere, and she's often the source of comic relief.
* She cares for the other objects: She's part of their close-knit community and enjoys their company.
Arguments for Babette having questionable morals:
* She's manipulative: She tries to convince Belle to stay in the castle by exaggerating the dangers of the outside world.
* She's selfish: She's obsessed with the idea of being a human again and isn't always considerate of others' feelings.
* She enables the Beast's arrogance: She fuels his belief that he's above human women and reinforces his anger and insecurities.
In conclusion: Babette is a character that embodies the struggle between wanting freedom and the desire for comfort. She is not truly evil, but her actions and motives are sometimes questionable, adding to her complexity and making her a fascinating character.