How Did Simonides Investigate Ben-Hur's Character?
Simonides does not investigate Ben-Hur. This conflates two distinct figures:
- Simonides of Ceos (c. 556–468 BCE) — Real ancient Greek lyric poet (invented memory palace / method of loci).
- Judah Ben-Hur — Fictional protagonist of Ben-Hur: A Tale of the Christ (1880) by Lew Wallace.
In the Novel: Who Investigates Ben-Hur?
Simonides (the character) — A wealthy merchant, former slave of the Hur family, living in Antioch. He investigates Ben-Hur's identity after Ben-Hur (now a Roman officer, Quintus Arrius's adopted son) reappears.
Simonides' Investigation Methods (Book 5, Ch. 1-3)
- Documents & Ledgers: Reviews Hur family records, financial accounts, slave manifests he secretly preserved for 8 years.
- Physical Examination: Compares Ben-Hur's body to childhood descriptions — scars, build, distinctive marks.
- Interrogation / Dialogue: Tests Ben-Hur's knowledge of family secrets, Hebrew prayers, household layout.
- Witness Corroboration: Questions his daughter Esther, loyal servants (Malluch), and the Egyptian magus Balthasar.
- Psychological Assessment: Observes Ben-Hur's demeanor, speech, values — "Is this the boy I knew, or a Roman impostor?"
Outcome
Convinced, Simonides restores the Hur fortune (vast wealth hidden in multiple currencies) to Ben-Hur, enabling his quest for vengeance and redemption. He becomes Ben-Hur's chief agent/financier.
Key: Simonides is a character in the novel, not the historical poet. Wallace gave him the name deliberately (memory/record-keeping).