Here's a breakdown:
Arguments for Dally being gallant:
* Protective of Johnny: Dally deeply cares for Johnny and risks his own safety to help him. He's fiercely loyal and protective of his friends, even though he's rough around the edges.
* Sacrificing himself: In the end, Dally intentionally gets himself killed by the police to ensure Johnny's safety. This act is undeniably brave and selfless.
* Chivalry towards Cherry: Dally shows a surprising degree of gentleness and understanding towards Cherry. He treats her with respect even when she's with Bob's friends.
Arguments against Dally being gallant:
* He's violent and rebellious: Dally is constantly getting into trouble and exhibits aggressive behavior. This is often due to a deep-seated sense of anger and frustration, but it's not necessarily a quality associated with gallantry.
* He's cynical and disillusioned: Dally has a hardened exterior and doesn't believe in the "good" in people. This cynicism makes it hard for him to be truly gallant, as gallantry often requires a belief in ideals and the desire to act on them.
* His actions are driven by desperation: Dally's actions are often motivated by fear, guilt, and a desire to escape his own pain. This is a far cry from the kind of noble motivation that characterizes gallantry.
Conclusion:
While Dally has some moments of compassion and bravery, his overall character is defined by his troubled past, rebellious nature, and cynicism. He might not fit the traditional definition of a gallant hero.
It's important to remember that "gallantry" can be a subjective term. Some readers might see Dally's actions as gallant because of their emotional impact and the sacrifices he makes. Others might find his methods and motivations too flawed to be truly heroic.