Are There Any Pros to Killing Duncan in Macbeth?
Are There Any Pros to Killing Duncan in Macbeth?
No. Within the world of the play, there are no “pros” to murdering King Duncan.
- Moral/Natural Order: Duncan is a virtuous, divinely appointed king. Regicide violates the Great Chain of Being, unleashing chaos (nature storms, horses eat each other).
- Macbeth’s Agency: The “pro” (becoming king) is the witches’ prophecy — already his fate. Murder is a choice to seize it prematurely, corrupting the outcome.
- Consequences: Immediate guilt, paranoia, further murders (Banquo, Macduff’s family), alienation from Lady Macbeth, tyranny, and eventual defeat/death.
- Lady Macbeth’s Fate: Her goading leads to her madness and suicide.
The play frames the act as a catastrophic moral error. Any perceived “gain” (crown) is hollow and self-destructive. The tragedy is the absence of justification.