Correction: Montague Does Not Kill Tybalt—Romeo Does
The premise is mistaken on two counts:
- Montague does not appear in Act 3, Scene 1. He enters later (3.1.140+) only after the Prince arrives.
- Montague never kills Tybalt. Romeo kills Tybalt in revenge for Mercutio's death.
Montague's role in the scene is solely to plead for Romeo's life before the Prince. The confusion likely stems from conflating the father (Montague) with the son (Romeo).