Does Macbeth Kill the Guards? Textual Clarification
No. In Shakespeare's Macbeth, Macbeth does not kill the guards (grooms/chamberlains) in the manner often assumed.
What Actually Happens (Act 2, Scene 3)
- Macduff discovers Duncan's murdered body.
- Macbeth claims he killed the guards in rage: "O, yet I do repent me of my fury, / That I did kill them."
- But this is a lie—Macbeth frames the guards (smears them with blood, plants daggers) while they're drugged unconscious by Lady Macbeth.
- The guards never wake to defend themselves; they're found dead (presumably killed by Macbeth offstage after the discovery, or the "killing" is part of the frame-up narrative).
Textual Ambiguity
Macbeth's line "I did kill them" is a performance for the thanes. Lady Macbeth faints (or feigns) to divert attention. The guards' actual deaths occur offstage; the play never shows them alive post-murder.
Why the Confusion?
- Macbeth says he killed them.
- Film adaptations (Polanski 1971, Kurzel 2015) often show the stabbing.
- The guards are the designated patsies—their deaths serve the cover-up.
Key Distinction
Macbeth kills Duncan (onstage/offstage), Banquo (via murderers), Macduff's family (via murderers), Young Siward (in battle). The guards are framed and silenced—not killed in combat or passion.