Arts >> Theater >> Comedy

The Making of a Villain: Origin Stories of the Wicked Witch of the West

Elphaba Thropp—the woman who becomes the Wicked Witch of the West—has haunted imaginations since L. Frank Baum introduced her in The Wonderful Wizard of Oz (1900). But Baum gave her no backstory. She simply was wicked. Later creators, unwilling to accept evil as innate, have crafted competing origin stories that transform a flat antagonist into a tragic figure.

The Born Outcast

Gregory Maguire's Wicked (1995) and its blockbuster musical adaptation popularized the most influential version: Elphaba is born different—green-skinned, sharp-toothed, physically unsettling. In a society obsessed with conformity, her very existence is an offense. Rejected by her father, misunderstood by peers, radicalized by injustice, she turns to witchcraft not from malice but from a desperate need for agency. Her "wickedness" is largely propaganda—a label slapped on a woman who refuses to be silent.

The Corrupted Idealist

Alternative versions (including some Oz sequels and film adaptations) portray a once-good witch whose desire for power—or love, or knowledge—twists her. This classic corruption arc frames wickedness as a choice, a gradual surrender to darker impulses. It's a more traditional morality tale but less psychologically nuanced.

Why the Origin Matters

The shift from "born wicked" to "made wicked" reflects a cultural evolution: we've moved from seeing evil as inherent to seeing it as constructed—by trauma, by oppression, by the stories powerful people tell about the powerless. Elphaba's transformation from one-dimensional villain to complex antihero mirrors our growing understanding that "wickedness" is usually a matter of perspective.

Whether born different or corrupted by power, Elphaba Thropp endures because she refuses to stay in the box Baum built for her. She demands we ask: Who benefits from calling her wicked?

Comedy

Related Categories