Both are icons, but their fame operates on different wavelengths.
Created in 1962 by Stan Lee and Steve Ditko, Spider-Man has saturated comics, films (8 live-action + animated), TV series (animated and live-action), video games, merchandise, and theme parks for over 60 years. He's recognized by children in Tokyo, grandparents in São Paulo, and everyone between. The mask makes him universally projectable.
Murphy exploded on SNL (1980–84), then dominated 80s/90s cinema: 48 Hrs., Beverly Hills Cop trilogy, Coming to America, The Nutty Professor, Shrek (voice). He defined Black crossover stardom and modern comedy stardom simultaneously. His influence on stand-up, sketch, and film comedy is immeasurable.
Murphy's impact is deeper in comedy and Black cultural history. Spider-Man's reach is broader across demographics, media, and geography. For universal recognition, the web-slinger wins. For transformative cultural force, Murphy stands tall. Both are Mt. Rushmore figures.