Arts >> Theater >> Comedy

What Does Johnny Say When He Kills Bob in The Outsiders? The Book Doesn't Say.

In S.E. Hinton's novel, Johnny kills Bob Sheldon in self-defense during a park confrontation. The text does not record Johnny's exact words at that moment.

The Scene

Ponyboy is nearly drowned by David. Johnny, terrified, stabs Bob. The narrative stays tight on Ponyboy's disorientation—he initially thinks he killed Bob. Johnny's dialogue afterward is minimal: "I had to. They were drowning you."

Why the Silence?

Film Adaptation (1983)

Ralph Macchio's Johnny also says little—mostly gasps and "Run, Ponyboy." The movie adds no memorable line.

The silence is the point: violence steals language.

Comedy

Related Categories