Snape Did Not Murder Dumbledore in Half-Blood Prince
It is a common misconception that Severus Snape "killed" Albus Dumbledore in the traditional sense. The truth is more nuanced:
- Dumbledore was dying from a cursed ring (Marvolo Gaunt's ring/Horcrux) and a potion (Drink of Despair) in the cave.
- Dumbledore planned his death with Snape to spare Draco Malfoy the burden, protect Snape's cover as a double agent, and cement Voldemort's trust in Snape.
- Snape cast the Killing Curse at Dumbledore's request—an act of mercy and loyalty, not murder.
- The plan served the greater goal of Voldemort's ultimate defeat.
Thus, Snape executed a pre-arranged, compassionate act under Dumbledore's explicit direction, making it an assisted death/sacrifice rather than a murder.