Storytelling:
* Compelling plot: A well-structured story with engaging conflicts, believable characters, and satisfying resolutions.
* Strong characters: Characters with depth, motivations, and relatable qualities, even if they're not "good" people.
* Interesting themes: The comic explores meaningful themes and concepts that resonate with the reader.
* Good pacing: The story unfolds at a natural pace, keeping the reader engaged without rushing or dragging.
Visuals:
* Dynamic art style: The art is visually appealing, expressive, and complements the story.
* Clear storytelling: The art effectively conveys action, dialogue, and emotions.
* Strong character design: Characters are memorable and distinct, visually communicating their personalities.
* Effective use of panel layout: The panels guide the reader's eye and contribute to the storytelling.
Writing:
* Strong dialogue: Dialogue sounds natural and reflects the characters' personalities.
* Engaging narration: The narrator's voice adds to the story and doesn't feel intrusive.
* Good use of wordplay: Humor, clever phrasing, and impactful word choices enhance the reading experience.
Beyond the Basics:
* Originality: The comic offers something fresh and unique, whether in its premise, characters, or art style.
* Emotional resonance: The story evokes strong emotions in the reader, making them connect with the characters and themes.
* Memorable moments: The comic features moments that stay with the reader long after they finish reading.
Ultimately, a "good" comic is one that resonates with the individual reader. What one person finds compelling, another might find boring. There's no single formula, but these elements are often present in highly regarded comics.