The coffin is empty. The creators of Pretty Little Liars intentionally left the occupant ambiguous to sustain the show's central mystery surrounding "A." The image—a lone coffin in a dimly lit room, the Liars standing around it in black dresses—functions as a symbol of pervasive threat rather than a literal plot point.
Showrunner I. Marlene King confirmed this in multiple interviews: the coffin represents the constant danger hovering over the four friends, the secrets they bury, and the unnamed body count of their tormentor's games. It's a visual thesis statement: someone is dead, someone is lying, and the truth is buried.
Fan theories have speculated everyone from Alison DiLaurentis to Maya St. Germain to "A" themselves, but the deliberate emptiness is the point. The mystery isn't who's in the coffin—it's what the coffin means.