Arguments for Obsession:
* Initial Attraction: Hughie is immediately smitten with Rae, showering her with attention and compliments. He seems eager to impress her and get close.
* Controlling Behavior: He becomes possessive and controlling, restricting her freedom and trying to manage her emotions. He even makes decisions for her without her consent, like steering the boat into the storm.
* Jealousy: Hughie shows jealousy and insecurity when Rae interacts with John, especially after discovering their past connection.
* Intrusive Thoughts: Hughie experiences disturbing dreams and nightmares, indicating an unhealthy fixation on Rae.
Arguments Against Obsession:
* Shared Trauma: Hughie and Rae bond over their shared experiences of grief and loss. This creates an emotional connection that goes beyond mere attraction.
* Fear and Vulnerability: Hughie's actions might stem from a fear of abandonment and a desire to protect Rae. His controlling behavior could be a desperate attempt to hold onto her.
* Redemption Arc: By the film's end, Hughie shows remorse for his actions and attempts to make amends. He seems to understand the extent of his mistakes and shows vulnerability.
Conclusion:
While Hughie displays some obsessive tendencies, the film doesn't explicitly label him as obsessed. His behavior is multifaceted, driven by a mix of attraction, fear, grief, and insecurity. Ultimately, it's left to the viewer to interpret the nuances of their relationship and decide whether Hughie's feelings crossed the line into obsession.