Arts >> Theater >> Comedy

Compare and contrast the apparent transformation of Alfred Doolittle into a gentleman in act 5 with lady?

Apparent Transformation of Alfred Doolittle into a Gentleman

* Begins by making several polite remarks to Higgins and Pickering

* "Good evening, gentlemen"

* "Allow me to introduce myself"

* Dresses in formal evening wear

* Previously described as wearing "unspeakably shabby clothes"

* Seems more educated

* Uses proper grammar

* References classical literature and philosophy

* Claims he now feels "middle class"

*Says he doesn't belong "in the gutter with the undeserving poor."

* Expresses gratitude towards Higgins for "making a man" out of him

* Accepts Higgins's offer of a partnership in his business

* Previously described as too proud to accept charity

Lady?

- Speaks in her usual, unrefined Cockney dialect.

- Dressed in her own clothes, not in formal evening wear.

- Doesn't seem to have acquired any more education.

- Hasn't changed her opinion about class; still thinks the upper class is unjust and hypocritical.

- Doesn't express any gratitude towards Higgins; in fact, she's still resentful of him.

- Rejects Higgins's offer of a job as a "flower girl" at his Covent Garden balls.

While Alfred Doolittle appears to have undergone a dramatic transformation into a gentleman, Lady remains largely unchanged. She's still the same outspoken, independent woman who she was at the beginning of the play. This shows that true social transformation is not as easy as it might seem. It requires more than just a change of clothes and manners. It also requires a change of heart.

Comedy

Related Categories