"Vanilla Twilight" (2009, Ocean Eyes) was written by Adam Young about a specific girlfriend at the time. He has confirmed the song is about a real person but never publicly revealed her name.
Fan speculation often cites "Shelby" or "Shelly" based on obscure forum posts, but Young has not confirmed this. The lyrics ("I'll watch the night turn light blue / But it's not the same without you") suggest a long-distance or ended relationship. The "vanilla twilight" metaphor evokes a sweet, pale, bittersweet memory.