"Miss New York" and "America's Sweetheart": Different Concepts
The question conflates two distinct things:
- "America's Sweetheart": Historical nickname for Mary Pickford (1892–1979), silent film star. Not a title won by Miss New York.
- Miss America: Pageant title. New York winners: Bess Myerson (1945), Mary Ann Mobley (1959), Vanessa Williams (1984 — resigned), Mallory Hagan (2013), Nina Davuluri (2014).
- Miss New York USA: State preliminary for Miss USA (different system).
No "Miss New York wins America" metric exists. Clarify which pageant/title is intended.