Holden Caulfield's inability to form intimate connections isn't simple teenage angst—it's a fortress built from grief, fear, and a desperate need to preserve innocence. His defenses converge in ways that make vulnerability feel like annihilation.
Holden equates adulthood with "phoniness." Intimacy feels like entrapment in a world he distrusts.
He feels fundamentally inferior and anticipates rejection, so he rejects first.
Allie's death and his parents' emotional absence taught him that love leads to loss. He protects against further grief by keeping everyone at arm's length.
Societal scripts—dating, marriage, career—strike him as inauthentic performances. He'd rather be alone than play a role.
Physical intimacy symbolizes a fall from childhood purity, the very thing his "catcher" fantasy tries to prevent.
These aren't separate issues; they're interlocking plates of armor. Holden's crisis reflects an adolescent identity struggle magnified by profound grief and alienation. He's not just avoiding intimacy—he's trying to survive it.