"Thanks for the Memories" (from 2007's Infinity on High) is a nostalgic tribute to past moments and shared experiences, not a song about romantic or sexual orientation.
The lyrics—"I'm gonna make it bend and break / It sent you to me without wings / Say a prayer but let the good times roll"—reflect on youthful recklessness, fleeting relationships, and gratitude for the memories created, however messy. Pete Wentz (lyricist) has described the song as "about looking back at a time in your life when things were chaotic but you were alive."
Fall Out Boy's theatrical aesthetic, Wentz's androgynous style, and the band's LGBTQ+ allyship sometimes lead listeners to read queer subtext into ambiguous lines. However, no band member or credible critic has identified homosexual themes in this specific track.
The song is about appreciation, nostalgia, and the bittersweet nature of memory—universal themes unrelated to sexual orientation.