“Stay” (2008, from Love on the Inside) was inspired by a friend’s torn relationship—unable to leave despite pain. Nettles told CMT:
“She was talking about how she was torn between staying and leaving… so many people have been there. I wanted to write a song that spoke to that indecision, and the hope that things might work out.”
The song captures the push-pull of a toxic yet binding love; won Grammy for Best Country Performance by Duo/Group.