Correction: “American Girl” is by Tom Petty and the Heartbreakers, released June 1977 on their self-titled debut album (recorded 1976).
The Eagles have a different song titled “American Girl” on One of These Nights (1975)—a lesser-known album track. Petty’s version is the iconic rock classic with the signature jangling Rickenbacker intro and driving Bo Diddley beat.
Two bands, two songs, same title. Petty’s is the one everyone knows.