Who Sang "September Song" in a 1950s Black-and-White Film Clip?
The description matches Eartha Kitt:
- 1950s rise to fame; sultry, distinctive voice
- Frequently performed "September Song" (Kurt Weill/Maxwell Anderson) in cabaret and TV
- Striking visual style – often in elegant gowns at intimate settings resembling dinner parties
- Black-and-white kinescopes/film clips of her TV appearances (The Ed Sullivan Show, Tonight Starring Steve Allen) circulate on YouTube
Other Possibilities
- Marlene Dietrich – recorded it 1940s, distinctive sprechstimme style
- Sarah Vaughan – jazz interpretation, later TV appearances
- Kay Starr – pop/jazz crossover, 1950s TV regular
But Kitt's persona – the "Edwardian dinner party" aesthetic, the purring vocal delivery, the visual elegance – fits the description best.
Without the exact clip, Eartha Kitt is the strongest candidate.