Cynthia Schloss never recorded "The First Cut Is the Deepest." The Jamaican singer (1948–1999) is known for reggae/soul classics like "Love Forever" and "Surround Me With Love"—but not this song.
The confusion may stem from Schloss's Jamaican heritage (Cat Stevens' version has a slight reggae lilt) or a simple attribution error. But the discography is clear: Schloss's beautiful voice graced other songs, not this one.