A common misconception needs correction: Irving Berlin wrote "God Bless America" but never sang it commercially. The song's public debut came from Kate Smith on her CBS radio show on November 10, 1938—a performance that made the song her signature and a national phenomenon.
Berlin composed the song in 1918 while serving in the Army, but set it aside. He revised it in 1938 as war loomed in Europe, specifically seeking a "peace song." He gave it to Smith, whose powerful contralto and massive radio audience (her show reached millions) made her the ideal vehicle.
Smith's rendition—earnest, unadorned, delivered with patriotic conviction—struck a chord with a nation on the brink of war. Her version became a de facto second national anthem, played at sporting events, political rallies, and school assemblies for decades.
Berlin's fame as America's songwriter ( "White Christmas," "Alexander's Ragtime Band," "There's No Business Like Show Business") leads people to assume he performed his own work. But Berlin was a composer/publisher, not a recording artist. His piano skills were modest (he played only in F-sharp major, using a transposing keyboard), and he never pursued a singing career.
If you're asking about the first performance, it's Kate Smith, November 10, 1938. If you're asking about the writer, it's Irving Berlin, 1918/1938. Two different roles, two different people.