Maxi Priest's 1991 reggae-pop cover of "Some Guys Have All the Luck" was a UK #2 hit and introduced the song to a new generation. But the original—recorded 14 years earlier by Rod Stewart—is a different animal entirely: grittier, looser, and steeped in the Faces' pub-rock swagger.
Released on Foot Loose & Fancy Free (Warner Bros.), produced by Tom Dowd. The band: Ronnie Wood (guitar), Billy Peek (guitar), Carmine Appice (drums), Phil Chen (bass), Gary Grainger (guitar), Phil Kenzie (sax). Recorded at Muscle Shoals and Cherokee Studios.
Stewart's vocal: raspy, conversational, slightly behind the beat. The arrangement: loose, jam-like, with a famous false start left in (Stewart laughs, "Take two"). The sax solo (Kenzie) is pure Stax soul. It peaked at #15 US / #25 UK — a modest hit overshadowed by "Tonight's the Night" from the same album.
From Bonafide (Charisma/Virgin). Produced by Sly & Robbie. Reggae groove, synth horns, polished production, Priest's smooth tenor. UK #2, US #60. The version most under-40s know.
Written by Jeff Fortgang (American songwriter, also wrote for Pointer Sisters, Chaka Khan). Stewart heard a demo, loved the "everyman resentment" lyric: "Some guys have all the luck / Some guys have all the pain / Some guys get all the breaks / Some guys do nothing but complain."
Stewart's version captures the song's class-conscious core: a working-stiff narrator watching the privileged glide. The Faces-era band plays it like a bar band that knows this life. Priest's version is beautiful—but it's a cover. The original is a testimony.