Did Carrie Underwood Sing "Jesus, Take the Wheel" on American Idol? No — Her Winning Song Was "Inside Your Heaven"
No. Carrie Underwood won American Idol Season 4 (2005) with her coronation single "Inside Your Heaven".
Timeline
- May 2005: Wins American Idol; releases "Inside Your Heaven" (debut single, #1 Billboard Hot 100).
- October 2005: Releases "Jesus, Take the Wheel" as lead single from debut album Some Hearts.
- Result: "Jesus, Take the Wheel" hit #1 on Hot Country Songs, #20 Hot 100, won Grammy — but was not performed on Idol.
Idol Performances
Her finale performances included "Independence Day," "Angels Brought Me Here," and "Inside Your Heaven." "Jesus, Take the Wheel" was recorded/post-Idol.