Common misconception: Vince Gill wrote "Apple of My Eye." He didn't.
The song was written by Jim Rushing and Terry Shelton, and recorded by Billy Ray Cyrus for his 1992 debut album Some Gave All (the one with "Achy Breaky Heart").
Gill is a prolific, award-winning songwriter ("Go Rest High on That Mountain," "When I Call Your Name," "Look at Us"), but this track isn't in his catalog. The confusion may stem from the song's mid-tempo, heartfelt country-pop feel—which sounds like a Gill composition—or from the Cyrus/Gill label-mate connection at Mercury/PolyGram.
Credit where it's due: Rushing and Shelton crafted a tender, fiddle-kissed ballad that became an album track favorite. Gill's catalog is immense; this just isn't part of it.