Is Downloading Music You Already Own (LP/CD/Tape) Illegal?
It depends on jurisdiction. General principles:
- Copyright Baseline: Unauthorized downloading of copyrighted works is typically infringement, regardless of ownership in another format.
- Format-Shifting Exceptions: Some countries permit personal-format shifting (e.g., CD → MP3 for own use) under "fair dealing" or "private copying" exceptions, often with levies on blank media.
- U.S. "Fair Use" (17 USC §107): No blanket format-shifting exemption. Courts have not definitively ruled non-commercial personal ripping as fair use; it remains a gray area. The RIAA has historically opposed it.
- Service Terms: Platform terms of service may prohibit downloading even if you own a physical copy.
Best Practice: Purchase/stream from authorized services (Bandcamp, iTunes, Amazon, Qobuz) or rip your own CDs legally where local law permits. Avoid unauthorized sources to eliminate risk.