Downloading vs. Recording Music: What Copyright Law Allows
The legal distinction lies in authorization, not the act of copying itself.
Downloading from the Internet
- Illegal if done without the copyright holder’s permission (most P2P, unauthorized sites).
- Legal via authorized stores (iTunes, Bandcamp, Amazon) or streaming subscriptions (Spotify, Apple Music) with offline download.
Recording from Radio
- Legal for personal use (US: Audio Home Recording Act 1992; similar laws elsewhere). Time-shifting/space-shifting allowed.
- Illegal to distribute/sell recordings—same as any unauthorized copy.
Core Principle
Copyright grants exclusive rights to reproduction, distribution, public performance, and derivative works. Both downloading and recording create copies. Legality depends on license or statutory exception.
- Radio recording → personal use exception (non-commercial, private).
- Internet download → no broad exception; requires license (purchase/subscription).
Ethical note: Support artists via legal channels. Streaming pays fractions of cents per play; purchases directly fund creators.