Neither is universally "better"—the choice depends entirely on your Pokémon, the opponent, and your strategy.
Pros: +2 Speed boost (doubles Speed), turning slow sweepers into fast threats. Great on physical attackers like Garchomp, Landorus-T, or Excadrill.
Cons: Only boosts Speed; useless against Ghost-types (immune to Rock moves if using Rock-type STAB); can be countered by Trick Room, priority, or faster Scarf users.
Pros: Paralyzes target (50% Speed cut, 25% full paralysis chance). Slows fast threats, aids slower teammates, works on special attackers. 90% accuracy.
Cons: Doesn't boost your Speed; Ground-types immune; Electric-types immune (Gen 6+); can be blocked by abilities (Limber, Volt Absorb) or items (Lum Berry); some threats ignore Speed control.
Example: Excadrill vs. Garchomp → Rock Polish Excadrill outspeeds and KOs. Alakazam vs. Landorus-T → Thunder Wave slows Landorus for Alakazam to revenge kill.