It's subjective, but they scratch different itches:
Strengths: Era-defining soundtrack ("Breaking Free," "We're All in This Together"), relatable high-school archetypes, breakout stars (Efron, Hudgens, Tisdale), massive nostalgia factor.
Weaknesses: Formulaic plot, theatrical staging can feel dated, sequels declined in quality.
Strengths: Powerhouse vocals (Demi Lovato, Joe Jonas), genre-blending soundtrack (pop/rock/R&B), themes of teamwork vs. individualism, higher production values, stronger choreography.
Weaknesses: "Battle of the bands" plot feels contrived, the titular "Final Jam" overstays its welcome, less cultural saturation.
Your preference likely hinges on which Disney Channel era you grew up with.