Pearl Jam has sold more records worldwide.
Both bands are diamond-certified (10M+ US sales) for multiple albums. Van Halen's peak commercial dominance was 1978–1995; Pearl Jam's has been steadier across three decades. Pearl Jam also leads in digital-era catalog consumption.
Note: Exact figures vary by source (RIAA, IFPI, label reports), but the consensus favors Pearl Jam by a modest margin.