Arts >> Music >> Other Music

Did J.S. Bach Write "Song of Prayer"? No—It's Mendelssohn

Despite the devotional title, "Song of Prayer" (Lied ohne Worte / "Song Without Words" Op. 109?) is not by Johann Sebastian Bach. The piece commonly referenced as "Song of Prayer" was composed by Felix Mendelssohn in 1847, the year of his death. It's one of his Lieder ohne Worte (Songs Without Words) for solo piano—short, lyrical miniatures that sing without text.

Why the Confusion?

Bach's sacred output (cantatas, passions, chorales) is so vast that any pious-sounding title gets attributed to him. But Mendelssohn, a key figure in the Bach revival (he conducted the St. Matthew Passion in 1829), wrote in a Romantic voice entirely his own—intimate, singing, and harmonically rich.

Mendelssohn's "Songs Without Words"

He published eight books (48 pieces total) between 1829–1845. "Song of Prayer" (sometimes Op. 109, No. 1 or similar) exemplifies the genre: a simple, hymn-like melody over flowing accompaniment, evoking private devotion. Bach would have recognized the piety, but the pianistic style is post-Beethoven.

So if you're playing a tender, Romantic piano piece titled "Song of Prayer," thank Felix, not Johann Sebastian.

Other Music

Related Categories