J.S. Bach in His Lifetime: The Virtuoso Organist, Not the "Great Composer"
If you asked a Leipzig townsman in 1740 "Who is Johann Sebastian Bach?", they’d say: "The finest organist in Germany. Maybe Europe." Not "the composer of the Brandenburg Concertos." Those gathered dust in his desk.
The Performer Reputation
- Organ testing: Cities hired him to inspect new organs — he’d play for hours, testing every stop, pedal, and resonance. His reports were technical treatises.
- Improvisation: Legendary. He could fugue on a theme for 30 minutes, weaving counterpoint in real time. Frederick the Great tested him in 1747 — Bach improvised a 3-voice fugue on the King’s theme, then a 6-voice on his own.
- Violin/Viola: Competent enough to lead court orchestras from the concertmaster chair (Cöthen, 1717–1723).
The Composer Blind Spot
- Published little in life: 4 clavier partitas, Well-Tempered Clavier Book 1, a few cantatas.
- Major works (Mass in B Minor, Art of Fugue, most cantatas, concertos) existed only in manuscript — copied by students/family for local use.
- Style considered "old-fashioned" (learned, contrapuntal) vs. galant/early Classical simplicity.
The Revival
1829: 20-year-old Felix Mendelssohn conducts St. Matthew Passion in Berlin — first performance since Bach’s death. The "Bach Revival" begins. By 1850, the Bach-Gesellschaft publishes complete works. The composer eclipses the performer.
Bach knew. He wrote on a manuscript: "S.D.G." — Soli Deo Gloria (To God Alone the Glory). He composed for eternity. He performed for Tuesday.