Ernie Isley Didn't Play the Iconic Sustain on "Who's That Lady" & "Summer Breeze" — It Was Randy Isley
Common misconception corrected: Ernie Isley (younger, later lead guitarist) did not play the legendary sustained lead lines on The Isley Brothers' "Who's That Lady" (1973) and "Summer Breeze" (1973 cover). It was his older brother Randy Isley.
The Technique: Volume Knob "Violining"
Recorded in 1973—before sustain pedals, compressors, or Floyd Rose tremolos were standard—Randy achieved vocal-like sustain on his Gibson ES-335 semi-hollowbody by:
- Fingerpicking (no pick) for softer attack.
- Rolling the guitar's volume knob up and down with his pinky/ring finger while sustaining notes.
- This swells each note's attack (volume off → on) and extends decay (volume on → off), mimicking a violin's bow.
Why It Matters
- Pure analog technique—no effects, just hands and instrument physics.
- Randy's touch: expressive, singing, deeply human.
- Ernie Isley (joined full-time later) developed his own style: more rock-oriented, wah-heavy, pentatonic.
Listen For It
"Who's That Lady" intro solo, "Summer Breeze" melodic leads — that's Randy's volume-knob violin. A lost art worth reviving.