Music in John Ford's "They Were Expendable" (1945): No "Green Berets," Just Herbert Stothart
A persistent myth claims the Vietnam-era ballad "The Ballad of the Green Berets" appears in John Ford's 1945 WWII film They Were Expendable. Impossible. The song was written and released by Staff Sgt. Barry Sadler in 1966—21 years after the film's release.
The Actual Score
- Composer: Herbert Stothart (MGM's premier musical director, Oscar winner for The Wizard of Oz).
- Style: Period-appropriate orchestral underscore—military motifs, nautical themes, dramatic leitmotifs for characters (Wayne, Montgomery, Ward).
- Source music: Diegetic use of period songs, bugle calls, shipboard ambience. No pop vocals.
Why the Confusion?
- Both involve American military themes.
- "Green Berets" became a cultural shorthand for "patriotic war song."
- Memory conflation: viewers associate the film's gravity with the later anthem.
They Were Expendable is a masterclass in wartime scoring—restrained, masculine, deeply felt. Stothart's work stands on its own; it needs no anachronistic assist.