Arts >> Music >> Musical Instruments

Dating a John M. Smyth Co. Faultless Mandolin

Background

John M. Smyth Co. (Chicago) sold Faultless brand mandolins c. 1895–1939.

Steps to Estimate Age

  1. Find the serial number (inside soundhole, back of headstock, or neck block).
  2. Consult reference lists: Mugwumps magazine, Frets journal, or online databases (Mandolin Cafe, Gruhn Guitars) have partial serial logs.
  3. Examine features:
    • Oval hole → earlier (pre-1920s)
    • F-holes → later (1920s+)
    • Adjustable truss rod → post-1920
    • Label style, tuners, tailpiece
  4. Contact experts: Vintage mandolin dealers (Elderly Instruments, Mandolin Brothers) or luthiers specializing in bowl-backs/flat-irons.

Value Note

Age alone doesn't determine value; condition, model, and playability matter more. Many Faultless mandolins are student-grade but collectible.

Musical Instruments

Related Categories