Dating a John M. Smyth Co. Faultless Mandolin
Background
John M. Smyth Co. (Chicago) sold Faultless brand mandolins c. 1895–1939.
Steps to Estimate Age
- Find the serial number (inside soundhole, back of headstock, or neck block).
- Consult reference lists: Mugwumps magazine, Frets journal, or online databases (Mandolin Cafe, Gruhn Guitars) have partial serial logs.
- Examine features:
- Oval hole → earlier (pre-1920s)
- F-holes → later (1920s+)
- Adjustable truss rod → post-1920
- Label style, tuners, tailpiece
- Contact experts: Vintage mandolin dealers (Elderly Instruments, Mandolin Brothers) or luthiers specializing in bowl-backs/flat-irons.
Value Note
Age alone doesn't determine value; condition, model, and playability matter more. Many Faultless mandolins are student-grade but collectible.