J.R.R. Tolkien and Music: What the Archives Actually Say
Short answer: No documented record exists of Tolkien’s personal listening habits, favorite composers, or opinions on contemporary music. He was a philologist and mythmaker — not a music critic.
What We Do Know
- Liturgical music: As a devout Catholic, he attended Latin Mass daily; Gregorian chant was his sonic baseline.
- Folk tradition: He loved English folk songs — collected them, referenced them in The Lord of the Rings (e.g., "The Man in the Moon Stayed Up Too Late").
- Poetry as music: His verse uses strict meter, alliteration, and rhyme — oral-formulaic techniques. He "heard" his poems before writing them.
- Donald Swann collaboration: He approved Swann’s The Road Goes Ever On (1967) — 7 songs from LOTR — and recorded a reading for the LP.
- Dislike of "program music": In letters, he criticized music that tried to "illustrate" his stories note-for-note (he preferred inspired independence).
What We Don’t
- Did he listen to Beethoven? Jazz? The Beatles? (He died in 1973; the Beatles broke up in 1970 — possible but unrecorded.)
- Did he play an instrument? No evidence.
- Did he have a "favorite" composer? Never stated.
The Lesson
Tolkien built languages with phonetic beauty — his music was linguistic. When he wrote "Sing all ye joyful," he didn’t need a soundtrack. The phonology the music.