That scene-stealing feline in Fall Out Boy's 2008 "I Don't Care" video? It's a puppet owned by Patrick Stump. No deep lore. No hidden symbolism. Just the lead singer's personal prop making a blink-and-you'll-miss-it cameo for pure absurdity.
The video—directed by Alan Ferguson, parodying celebrity culture, paparazzi, and the band's own rising fame—is packed with surreal gags: Pete Wentz as a tabloid target, Andy Hurley as a confused bystander, Joe Trohman as... himself, mostly. The cat puppet pops up for a few seconds, gets manhandled, and vanishes. Stump later confirmed in interviews it was just a silly on-set joke that made the final cut.
So no, the cat doesn't represent the band's id, the music industry's predatory nature, or Pete's soul. It's a puppet. Patrick thought it was funny. End of mystery.