Who Was the First Indie Band? The Debate Explained
"First Indie Band" – No Consensus, Several Contenders
"Indie" = Independent label/distribution, not a genre. The term crystallized in the late 1970s/early 1980s UK music press (NME, indie charts). Because the definition shifted over time—from label status to sound to ethos to marketing category—there is no single answer.
Top Contenders
- The Velvet Underground (1965–) – On Verve (MGM subsidiary) but with artistic autonomy; White Light/White Heat rejected by label. Inspired DIY ethos.
- The Monochrome Set (1978–) – Debut "He's Frank" (1979) on Rough Trade (first true indie label). Early "indie pop" sound.
- Joy Division (1976–) – Factory Records (1978). Defined post-punk/indie aesthetic.
- The Fall (1976–) – Step-Forward (indie), then Rough Trade. Prolific, uncompromising.
- Buzzcocks – Spiral Scratch EP (1977, New Hormones) – **First self-released punk/indie record** (Manchester).
- The Feelies (1976–) – Stiff (indie), NJ scene; jangly, minimalist.
- Television (1973–) – Elektra (major) but CBGB roots; Marquee Moon indie spirit.
- Minutemen / Hüsker Dü / Black Flag (US, 1978–) – SST (indie). Hardcore → indie rock bridge.
- R.E.M. (1980–) – Hib-Tone (indie single "Radio Free Europe"), then I.R.S. (indie label). First indie band to go mainstream.
- The Smiths (1982–) – Rough Trade. Defined 80s UK indie.
Why No Single Answer?
- "Indie" evolved: label status → sound → ethos → marketing category.
- US vs. UK trajectories differ (SST vs. Rough Trade/Factory).
- Pre-history: 60s garage, 70s pub rock, DIY punk all prefigured it.
Most cited: Buzzcocks – Spiral Scratch (1977) as first self-released indie record; Joy Division / The Fall / The Smiths as first definitive indie bands.