The Spice Girls are the best-selling girl group in history (85M+ records). The metrics aren't close:
Girls Aloud (21 UK top 10s, 4 #1s, 5 studio albums) are the most successful UK reality-TV group and critically acclaimed (NME "best girl group"), but commercial scale is an order of magnitude smaller.
Spice Girls didn't just sell records — they sold a movement. Girls Aloud made better records; Spice Girls made history.