No objective answer exists—"greatest" is subjective. Each has compelling claims:
Unmatched songwriting innovation, studio revolution, cultural impact, melodic/harmonic sophistication; 1960–1970 compressed timeline; influence on virtually all subsequent pop/rock.
Longevity (60+ years), raw blues-rock identity, iconic riffs/frontman, touring juggernaut, cultural rebellion symbol; "World's Greatest Rock & Roll Band" self-mythology realized.
Hard rock/blueprint for heavy metal; Page's production/guitar, Plant's vocals, Bonham's drums, Jones's bass/keys; albums 1–IV + Physical Graffiti = canonical; massive influence on rock/metal.
Verdict: Choose the band whose music moves you most. All three are foundational.