There is no record of an Old Spice commercial titled "Guitar Goon" from 2009 or any year.
Old Spice's landmark 2009 campaign was "The Man Your Man Could Smell Like" starring Isaiah Mustafa. It featured a single, charismatic lead in continuous takes—no ensemble cast, no "goon" character.
If you recall specific dialogue ("Look at your man, now back to me"), visuals (shower → boat → horse), or music, share those—they point squarely to the Mustafa campaign.